12.5 BURNING TO DEFRAUD INSURER

Official jury instruction text reproduced for information. It is not legal advice; the instruction given in a case depends on the facts and the court.

Burning to Defraud an Insurer Charges in Miami-Dade

Burning to Defraud Insurer | Florida Standard Jury Instruction (Criminal) 12.5 | § 817.233, Fla. Stat.

This charge is about a fire and an insurance policy. Florida law covers a person who willfully and with intent to injure or defraud the insurer sets fire to or burns, or attempts to, or who causes to be burned or aids, counsels, or procures the burning of, any building, structure, or personal property that is insured at the time against loss or damage by fire. The statute covers property of the person or of another.

The statute makes a violation a felony of the third degree. These cases often start with a fire investigation and an insurance claim, and the case may turn on proof of how the fire started, who was responsible, and what the person intended.

What the State Must Prove

The State carries the whole burden. To convict, it must prove every element below beyond a reasonable doubt. These words are from the official instruction the judge reads to the jury (Florida Standard Jury Instructions in Criminal Cases, 12.5). Words in brackets and parentheses are choices the judge fills in for the actual case.

To prove the crime of Burning to Defraud an Insurer, the State must prove the following four elements beyond a reasonable doubt:

  1. (Defendant)

[set fire to]

[burned]

[attempted to set fire to]

[attempted to burn]

[caused to be burned]

[aided, counseled, or procured the burning of]

(building, structure, or personal property alleged).

  1. The property belonged to (person alleged).

  2. The property was insured against loss or damage by fire.

  3. (Defendant) acted willfully and with a fully-formed, conscious intent to injure or defraud the insurer of the property.

Read the official text and the full instruction on our Elements of the Crime page.

What That Means in Plain English

  • The State must prove you set fire to, burned, attempted to set fire to or burn, caused to be burned, or aided, counseled, or procured the burning of, the building, structure, or personal property named in the charge.
  • It must prove the property belonged to the person named.
  • It must prove the property was insured against loss or damage by fire at the time.
  • It must prove you acted willfully and with a fully-formed, conscious intent to injure or defraud the insurer of the property.

Common Defenses

Every case is different. Here are some of the areas a defense lawyer may look at.

  • The cause of the fire. A lawyer may ask how the State says the fire started and who started it. A lawyer may review the fire investigation reports and ask what other causes were considered.
  • Your role. The instruction lists several roles, such as setting the fire, causing it to be burned, or aiding, counseling, or procuring it. A lawyer may ask which role the State claims and what proof supports it.
  • Insurance in effect. The third element requires that the property was insured against loss by fire at the time. A lawyer may check the policy, its dates, and its terms.
  • Intent to defraud the insurer. The fourth element requires a fully-formed, conscious intent to injure or defraud the insurer. A lawyer may ask what shows that intent, and look at the financial records the State uses to claim a motive.
  • Ownership. A lawyer may check who owned the property, and what the records show.

How a Defense Lawyer Looks for Reasonable Doubt

The State has to prove each element. A lawyer may test each one.

  • Get the fire department and fire marshal reports, photographs, and lab results.
  • Obtain the full insurance policy, the claim file, and every statement given to the insurer.
  • Review financial records and compare them to the State's theory of motive.
  • Look at who had access to the property, and where each person was at the time.

What to Do Right Now

  • Do not discuss the case with the police or on social media before you speak to a lawyer.
  • Write down what happened while you remember it, and keep your papers, texts, and photos.
  • Do not contact the other person if a judge told you not to.
  • Call us early. Deadlines in criminal cases move fast.

Talk to a Lawyer

Charged, or think you may be? Call (305) 209-0384 for a free consultation. We answer 24/7. Se habla español.

This page is general information, not legal advice, and it does not create a lawyer-client relationship. Every case depends on its own facts, and no result is promised.

Download the official instruction (PDF)

Source: The Florida Bar, edition of October 9, 2026. Always check the official site for the latest version. Backup copy (PDF)

Instruction
12.5
Statute
§ 817.233, Fla. Stat.
Edition
Florida Standard Jury Instructions in Criminal Cases, complete set published by The Florida Bar, updated October 9, 2026
Official source
The Florida Bar: criminal jury instructions

Elements

Quoted word for word from the official text. Florida Standard Jury Instructions in Criminal Cases, complete set published by The Florida Bar, updated October 9, 2026.

To prove the crime of Burning to Defraud an Insurer, the State must prove the following four elements beyond a reasonable doubt:

1. (Defendant)

[set fire to]

[burned]

[attempted to set fire to]

[attempted to burn]

[caused to be burned]

[aided, counseled, or procured the burning of]

(building, structure, or personal property alleged).

2. The property belonged to (person alleged).

3. The property was insured against loss or damage by fire.

4. (Defendant) acted willfully and with a fully-formed, conscious intent to injure or defraud the insurer of the property.

Lesser-included offenses

As the instruction lists them, word for word.

BURNING TO DEFRAUD INSURER — 817.233

CATEGORY ONECATEGORY TWOFLA. STAT.INS. NO.
None
Attempt777.04(1)5.1

Related practice page

Arson Defense in Miami

Official source: The Florida Bar: criminal jury instructions

Official jury instruction text reproduced for information. It is not legal advice; the instruction given in a case depends on the facts and the court.

Request ConsultationConsult Call 24 hoursCall 24/7 (305) 209-0384 Text us WhatsApp