12.4(a) CRIMINAL MISCHIEF – [MEMORIAL] [HISTORIC PROPERTY]
Official jury instruction text reproduced for information. It is not legal advice; the instruction given in a case depends on the facts and the court.
Criminal Mischief to a Memorial or Historic Property Charges in Miami-Dade
Criminal Mischief - [Memorial] [Historic Property] | Florida Standard Jury Instruction (Criminal) 12.4(a) | § 806.13(3), Fla. Stat.
This charge is about damaging a memorial or historic property. The statute covers a person who, without the consent of the owner, willfully and maliciously defaces, injures, or otherwise damages a memorial or historic property, when the value of the damage is greater than $200. The two terms are defined in section 806.135(1), so the first question in many cases is whether the property fits.
The statute makes a violation of this subsection a felony of the third degree. It also says a court shall order a person convicted to pay restitution, which includes the full cost of repair or replacement. A memorial under the statute includes a plaque, statue, marker, flag, banner, cenotaph, religious symbol, painting, seal, tombstone, structure name, or display, if it meets the other parts of the definition. Historic property means a building, structure, site, or object officially designated as historic through a federal, state, or local designation program.
What the State Must Prove
The State carries the whole burden. To convict, it must prove every element below beyond a reasonable doubt. These words are from the official instruction the judge reads to the jury (Florida Standard Jury Instructions in Criminal Cases, 12.4(a)). Words in brackets and parentheses are choices the judge fills in for the actual case.
To prove the crime of Criminal Mischief – [Memorial] [Historic Property], the State must prove the following four elements beyond a reasonable doubt:
(Defendant) defaced, injured, or damaged [a memorial] [historic property].
The [memorial] [historic property] was defaced, injured, or damaged without the consent of the owner.
The defacement, injury, or damage was done willfully and maliciously.
The damage to the [memorial] [historic property] was greater than $200.
Read the official text and the full instruction on our Elements of the Crime page.
What That Means in Plain English
- The State must prove you defaced, injured, or damaged a memorial, or historic property, as the charge names it.
- It must prove that was done without the consent of the owner.
- It must prove the defacement, injury, or damage was done willfully and maliciously.
- It must prove the damage was greater than $200. The amount is part of the charge, so exactly how it was counted matters.
Common Defenses
Every case is different. Here are some of the areas a defense lawyer may look at.
- Is it a memorial or historic property. The statute has detailed definitions. A lawyer may compare the property to them, including whether it was officially designated as historic.
- Consent of the owner. A lawyer may ask who the owner is and what the owner allowed or knew.
- Willful and malicious. A lawyer may ask what shows you acted willfully and maliciously, and not by accident or carelessness.
- The amount. The instruction says the damage must be greater than $200. A lawyer may ask how the value of the damage was figured, by whom, and with what paperwork. The statute also says amounts of damage to property owned by separate persons may be aggregated if done in one scheme or course of conduct, so a lawyer may ask whether the State relies on that.
- Who did it. A lawyer may ask what ties you to the act, and what other people were present or had access.
How a Defense Lawyer Looks for Reasonable Doubt
The State has to prove each element. A lawyer may test each one.
- Get the repair estimates, invoices, and photographs the State relies on, and compare the figures to what was actually done.
- Check the historic designation records, including the date and the program that designated it.
- Review video, witness statements, and any physical evidence for who was there.
- Look at the property owner's records on who had permission to be there.
What to Do Right Now
- Do not discuss the case with the police or on social media before you speak to a lawyer.
- Write down what happened while you remember it, and keep your papers, texts, and photos.
- Do not contact the other person if a judge told you not to.
- Call us early. Deadlines in criminal cases move fast.
Talk to a Lawyer
Charged, or think you may be? Call (305) 209-0384 for a free consultation. We answer 24/7. Se habla español.
This page is general information, not legal advice, and it does not create a lawyer-client relationship. Every case depends on its own facts, and no result is promised.
Source: The Florida Bar, edition of October 9, 2026. Always check the official site for the latest version. Backup copy (PDF)
- Instruction
- 12.4(a)
- Statute
- § 806.13(3), Fla. Stat.
- Edition
- Florida Standard Jury Instructions in Criminal Cases, complete set published by The Florida Bar, updated October 9, 2026
- Official source
- The Florida Bar: criminal jury instructions
Elements
Quoted word for word from the official text. Florida Standard Jury Instructions in Criminal Cases, complete set published by The Florida Bar, updated October 9, 2026.
To prove the crime of Criminal Mischief – [Memorial] [Historic Property], the State must prove the following four elements beyond a reasonable doubt:
1. (Defendant) defaced, injured, or damaged [a memorial] [historic property].
2. The [memorial] [historic property] was defaced, injured, or damaged without the consent of the owner.
3. The defacement, injury, or damage was done willfully and maliciously.
4. The damage to the [memorial] [historic property] was greater than $200.
Lesser-included offenses
As the instruction lists them, word for word.
CRIMINAL MISCHIEF [MEMORIAL] [HISTORIC PROPERTY] — 806.13(3)
| CATEGORY ONE | CATEGORY TWO | FLA. STAT. | INS. NO. |
|---|---|---|---|
| Criminal Mischief | 806.13(1)(b)1 | 12.4 | |
| Criminal Mischief | 806.13(1)(b)3 | 12.4 | |
| Criminal Mischief | 806.13(1)(b)2 | 12.4 | |
| Attempt | 777.04(1) | 5.1 |
Related practice page
Criminal Mischief and Vandalism Defense in Miami
Official source: The Florida Bar: criminal jury instructions
Official jury instruction text reproduced for information. It is not legal advice; the instruction given in a case depends on the facts and the court.